Ryan's Universe - Comments

Tony Shimkin: Starting a Band - Step 2: Recruiting Members

nospam@example.com (Tony Shimkin) — Mon, 07 Jun 2010 10:05:50 -0500

Be clear on what you expect from your collaboration. Make sure to be let prospective band mates on what you are you looking for, a musician only or a writing partner and co-creative force.

Tony Shimkin: Starting a Band - Step 2: Recruiting Members

nospam@example.com (Tony Shimkin) — Mon, 07 Jun 2010 10:02:02 -0500

I'd add that looking within existing bands is a must. Many musicians are willing to or do play in more than one band. Seeing someone onstage already in a band is the best way to judge their musicianship and stage presence. If they jump ship too quickly from the band you found them playing with, be wary as they may do the same to you. Yes chemistry is everything. If you want longevity as a band, have a clear vision that you all share and you must have trust, respect and an ability to work through creative differences.

Heather: Starting a Band - Step 1: Brainstorming

nospam@example.com (Heather) — Mon, 19 Apr 2010 13:13:03 -0500

Very good advice! A LOT of people skip this step. All good points, but I think your first and last ones are my favorites. You have got to be on the same page in terms of the "end game" when you form a band. If you're thinking "I hope we can book a three week tour" and your bandmate is thinking "I am going to have to cancel practice tonight so I can work late", you're going to have a problem. Like you said, there is nothing wrong with either approach, but everyone in the band needs to be on the same page on what exactly the band is going to try to accomplish.

And yes! Definitely decide who is in charge of what! As you say, this can help you figure out what to look for in a band member (besides, you know, musical ability of course). This step is also really important if the band is going to be handling book, promotion, etc in-house. It is helpful for all of the people who need to communicate with the band to have one point of contact. It is less confusing for them and it helps stop things from slipping through the cracks on the band's end ("But I thought you were going to confirm that show!").

Great advice, Ryan!